Reducing Restaurant Overtime: A Complete Guide for Managers

Overtime pay at 1.5 times the regular rate adds up fast. A single employee working five extra hours a week costs you the equivalent of 7.5 hours of labor—and that’s before you factor in the burnout, the scheduling chaos, and the ripple effects on the rest of your team.

The fix isn’t complicated, but it does require intention. This guide covers the root causes of restaurant overtime, eight practical ways to reduce it, and how to get your managers on board without sacrificing service or losing your best people.

What causes overtime in restaurants?

Before you can fix overtime, you have to understand what’s causing it. Most overtime isn’t intentional. It creeps in through scheduling gaps, last-minute scrambles, and a lack of visibility into who’s working how many hours.

Poor schedule planning

When you build schedules based on gut feeling instead of projected sales, you end up overstaffing slow shifts and understaffing busy ones. Both lead to overtime. Overstaffing means you’re paying for hours you don’t need. Understaffing means your scheduled team works longer to keep up, and those extra hours add up fast.

Last-minute call-outs and no-shows

Every time someone calls out, you’re scrambling to fill the gap. And who do you call? Usually, your most reliable people are the same ones who are already working four or five shifts that week. Before you know it, they’ve crossed 40 hours.

Inaccurate sales forecasting

Sales forecasting means using historical data to predict how busy you’ll be on any given day. Without it, you’re guessing. Guess wrong, and you either have too many people standing around or not enough hands to handle the rush. The latter almost always results in overtime.

No real-time visibility into hours worked

Here’s where most managers get caught: they don’t know who’s approaching overtime until they run payroll. By then, it’s too late. The hours are already worked, and you’re paying time-and-a-half whether you planned to or not.

Understaffing during peak periods

Running lean during a Friday dinner rush might seem like a way to save on labor. But when your three servers are handling the work of five, they’re staying late to close out tables, roll silverware, and finish sidework. That “savings” turns into overtime real quick.

How to reduce restaurant overtime

Reducing overtime isn’t about cutting hours across the board. It’s about scheduling smarter, so you have the right people working the right shifts, without anyone accidentally crossing that 40-hour threshold.

1. Build schedules based on sales forecasts

Pull your sales data from the same week last year, or at least the past few weeks. Look at covers, revenue by daypart, and any events or holidays that affected traffic. Then match your staffing to those numbers.

If last Tuesday did $2,800 in sales with four servers, don’t schedule six this Tuesday unless something’s changed.

2. Set your labor budget before you start scheduling

Decide on your target labor cost or total hours before you start dragging names onto the schedule. This forces discipline. If your budget is 180 hours for the week and you’ve already scheduled 160 by Thursday, you know you have to be conservative with the weekend.

3. Track employee hours in real time

Don’t wait until payroll to find out who worked overtime. Check accumulated hours daily, or better yet, use a system that tracks them automatically. If you’re doing this manually, a simple spreadsheet updated each morning works. The goal is visibility before it’s too late.

4. Set up overtime alerts for managers

The best time to prevent overtime is when someone hits 32 hours, not 40. Set up alerts that flag employees approaching the threshold. This gives you time to adjust their remaining shifts or find coverage elsewhere.

5. Cross-train employees across multiple positions

A server who can host. A line cook who can prep. A bartender who can expo. Cross-training creates flexibility. When you need to fill a gap, you can move someone already on the clock instead of calling in a person who’s at 38 hours.

6. Enforce clock-in and clock-out policies

Small overages compound. If employees clock in 10 minutes early every shift, that’s nearly an hour of extra time per week, per person.

• Set clear rules: No clocking in more than five minutes before a shift
• Require clock-outs for breaks: Unpaid breaks mean unpaid time
• End shifts on time: Clock out immediately after sidework is done

7. Use shift swapping to fill coverage gaps

When someone calls out, your first instinct is to call your most reliable closer. But if they’re already at 36 hours, you’re buying overtime. Instead, let employees swap shifts among themselves with manager approval. Someone who’s only worked two shifts that week might be happy to pick up an extra one.

8. Review overtime reports weekly

Make it a habit. Every Monday, look at who worked overtime the previous week, why it happened, and whether it was avoidable. Patterns emerge quickly. Maybe it’s always the same two people. Maybe it’s always Saturday night. Use that information to adjust future schedules.

How to train your managers to prevent overtime

You can have the best systems in place, but if your managers aren’t bought in, overtime will keep creeping back. This isn’t about micromanaging. It’s about giving them the tools and accountability to make better decisions.

Set clear expectations around overtime approval

Remove the assumption that overtime “just happens.” Create an approval process: who can authorize overtime, under what circumstances, and how it gets documented. When overtime requires a conversation instead of a shrug, people think twice.

Give managers access to real-time labor data

Managers can’t fix what they can’t see. Make sure they have access to current hours worked by employee, projected hours for the week, and labor cost versus budget. Whether that’s a dashboard in your scheduling software or a shared spreadsheet, the data has to be visible and updated.

Hold managers accountable for labor cost targets

Tie overtime and labor cost performance to manager goals. Review it weekly during your check-ins, not just at annual reviews. When managers know they’ll be asked about last week’s overtime, they pay closer attention to this week’s schedule.

Scheduling software features that help reduce overtime

Technology won’t solve overtime on its own, but the right tools make prevention a lot easier. Look for software (like 7shifts) with these features:

Real-time labor cost tracking

The ability to see your labor spend as you build the schedule, before you publish it, prevents over-scheduling from the start. You’ll know if you’re trending over budget before anyone works a single shift.

Automated overtime alerts and notifications

Software that automatically flags employees approaching 40 hours and notifies managers via push notification or email takes the guesswork out of tracking. You don’t have to remember to check. The system does it for you.

Sales forecasting integration

When your scheduling software connects to your POS, it can pull in sales data to predict staffing needs. No more guessing based on memory. The system shows you what last Tuesday actually looked like, so you can staff this Tuesday accordingly.

Mobile schedule access for your team

When employees can see their schedules and available shifts on their phones, they can swap shifts without you playing middleman for every change. Tools like 7shifts let your team handle availability, time-off requests, and shift trades in one place, which means fewer frantic texts to you when someone needs coverage.

Manual Approach	With Scheduling Software
Track hours on a spreadsheet, update daily	Hours update automatically as employees clock in/out
Calculate overtime risk manually each day	Automatic alerts when approaching thresholds
Call or text employees to find coverage	Employees pick up or swap shifts in the app
Review overtime after payroll runs	See labor costs in real time while building the schedule

Tip: If you’re still building schedules in Excel or on paper, you’re spending time you don’t have. Scheduling software like 7shifts calculates labor costs in real time as you build, so you can catch overtime before it happens. Start a free trial to see how it works.

How to cut overtime without losing good employees

Here’s the fear: if you reduce hours, your best people will leave for a restaurant that gives them more. It’s a valid concern. But cutting overtime doesn’t have to mean cutting morale, if you handle it right.

Communicate your overtime policy clearly

Have an honest conversation with your team about why you’re reducing overtime. Frame it around fairness and sustainability, not just cost-cutting. Most employees understand that a restaurant running on constant overtime isn’t healthy for anyone.

Offer schedule flexibility instead of extra hours

Some employees value predictability over extra shifts. Others want the ability to pick up hours when they’re available. Find out what your team actually wants.

Distribute hours fairly across your team

When the same three people get all the extra shifts, they end up in overtime while everyone else feels overlooked. Spread available hours across more employees. This prevents overtime and improves retention for those who want more work.

• Track hour distribution: Review which employees are getting the most hours and whether it’s creating overtime risk
• Give newer employees a fair shot: Don’t always default to your veterans for extra shifts
• Consider employee preferences: Some want maximum hours; others prefer a set schedule

Restaurant overtime laws managers need to know

Overtime isn’t just a budget issue. It’s a legal one. Getting it wrong can lead to back-pay claims, penalties, and lawsuits.

Federal overtime requirements

Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), non-exempt employees earn overtime pay at 1.5 times their regular rate for any hours worked over 40 in a workweek. A “workweek” is any fixed, recurring 168-hour period. It doesn’t have to be Monday through Sunday. For current details, check the U.S. Department of Labor website.

State-specific daily overtime rules

Some states require daily overtime, meaning employees earn time-and-a-half after working a certain number of hours in a single day, not just weekly. Requirements vary significantly by state. Check your state department of labor website for specific rules.

Overtime calculations for tipped employees

Overtime for tipped workers is calculated on the full minimum wage, not the lower tipped wage. This catches many operators off guard. If you’re unsure how to calculate overtime for your tipped staff, consult with a payroll professional.

Important: Labor laws vary significantly by state and locality. This is general information, not legal advice. Check your state department of labor and consult with an employment attorney or HR professional for your specific situation.

Take control of your labor costs with smarter scheduling

Overtime isn’t inevitable. It’s a symptom of scheduling gaps you can fix. Forecast your sales, set your labor budget before you start scheduling, track hours in real time, and hold your managers accountable.

The restaurants that get this right don’t just save money. They build more predictable schedules, reduce manager stress, and create a fairer environment for their teams.

Ready to see how much overtime is costing you? Start a free trial of 7shifts and get real-time visibility into your labor costs.

Related watch: What should your restaurant labor cost percentage be?

FAQs about reducing restaurant overtime

How much overtime is normal for a restaurant?

There’s no universal benchmark. It depends on your concept, staffing model, and local labor market. Some overtime during holidays or special events is expected. The goal is to make overtime intentional, planned for known busy periods, rather than accidental.

Can I send employees home early to avoid overtime later in the week?

In most cases, yes. However, some states and localities have “reporting time” or “show-up pay” rules that require minimum compensation when employees report for a scheduled shift. Check your local labor laws, and communicate schedule changes as early as possible.

How do I handle employees who ask for more overtime hours?

Have an honest conversation about your labor budget and scheduling constraints. If they need more income, explore options like picking up shifts at other locations, cross-training into roles that need coverage, or adjusting their regular schedule to give them more base hours without crossing into overtime.